“Ten year old, Gradon got some nasty news from his
dentist and it wasn’t a cavity,” reports CBC-TV. “I saw this yellow
stuff and thought it was my toothpaste and kept trying to wash
it off; but it wouldn’t come off,” says Gradon.
Those patches are fluorosis, a condition that shocks many parents
because of the cause -- too much fluoride. “It was even a bigger
surprise to his pediatric dentist -- he’s Gradon’s father,” said
the Canadian broadcaster. (1)
“We don’t really know how much fluoride it takes to cause fluorosis;
and it’s not something we really knew much about ten years ago,”
said the Canadian dentist in 1998.
Dental fluorosis is growing in prevalence and severity in American
children (2) and can range from mild, white spotted teeth to moderate
and severe fluorosis -- yellow, brown or black and sometimes pitted
and crumbling teeth.
American children are over-fluoridated. It’s hard to believe
that dentists themselves are undereducated about fluoride and
its adverse effects, but they are.
Some dentists and pediatricians wrongly prescribe fluoride supplements
to children who live in fluoridated communities. Further, the
Center for Disease Control (CDC) teaches dentists that fluoride
supplements and fluoride treatments by dentists are only advisable
for those with a high risk for tooth decay (3), although doctors
usually prescribe supplements based on water fluoridation status,
age and fluoride treatments based on insurance carriers’ willingness
to pay. The only scientifically-valid predictor of future cavities
is present tooth decay.
Fluoride treatments may be a money-maker for dentists, but there’s
no proof it benefits children at low risk for tooth decay. (4)
Fluoride’s alleged beneficial effects are topical, not systemic
as once believed. Scientists discovered that fluoride supplements
discolor teeth but don’t reduce tooth decay. (5)
That is why mainstream dental groups such as the Canadian Dental
Association, the Western Australia Health Department's Dental
Service and the German Scientific Dental Association stopped recommending
routine fluoride supplementation, unlike the American Dental Association
who still recommends supplements, not based on patient need, scientific
evidence or CDC guidelines, but on water fluoridation status and
age.
And to add insult to injury, fluoride supplements have never
been approved or safety tested by the FDA (U.S. Food and Drug
Administration), having been “grandfathered” in, (already being
sold) before the law to test drugs was passed (6).
In the early 1900’s, Americans drinking naturally calcium-fluoridated
water supplies displayed cavity-free but discolored teeth. Fluoride,
the tooth staining culprit, was assumed the cavity preventer,
also. But researchers overlooked calcium, magnesium and other
teeth-building components in the water supplies.
Those early studies are dismissed as flawed. (7) But, still not
ready to give up on fluoride, dentists claim fluoride must work
topically. However, no well-done studies exist comparing cavity
rates between similar populations of fluoride users vs. non-users.
Neither a nutrient nor essential to health, fluoride is simply
used as a drug to treat tooth decay. Unlike vitamin and mineral
supplements discouraged in favor of a balanced diet, fluoride
supplements are promoted by the medical establishment and mandated
into water supplies, even though slightly more than recommended
leads to adverse effects such as dental fluorosis. Three to four
times “optimal” can actually cause tooth decay. (8)
In larger amounts, fluoride is lethal. But some dentists are
painfully unaware of this, too.
In order to convince California legislators to vote for fluoridation,
a dentist swallowed a whole vial of fluoride tablets in front
of them and then said, “Hey, guess what? I’m still alive.” (9)
Swallowing too many fluoride pills killed children. (10) Another
child died after swallowing instead of expectorating his dentist’s
fluoride treatment. The dentist didn’t think it was toxic. (11)
People have become sickened and died because water engineers or
machinery malfunction injected excess fluoride into water supplies.
(12)
Warnings on the back of fluoridated toothpaste tubes and boxes
are there because ingestion of the whole tube’s contents can be
lethal to a small child. (10)
Over 65% of America is fluoridated, and virtually all Americans
consume too much fluoride in their foods, beverages and dental
products. With dental fluorosis increasing, one would expect tooth
decay would be obliterated.
Instead tooth decay rates climb. (13)
The only virtual sure thing that’s linked to extensive cavities
is poverty, which is also linked to poor nutrition, high rates
of infant mortality, higher cancer death rates, and most other
health disorders. Unlike nutrients which have deficiency health
consequences, fluoride deficiency has no health consequences.
Dentist Weston Price discovered in the 1920s and ‘30s that “primitive”
populations around the world who followed their traditional nature-based
diets enjoyed decay-free teeth, while those that turned to the
“civilized” diet of processed, sugar-laden foods had many missing
and decayed teeth. (14)
There are ways to help prevent tooth decay in children. The American
Dental Association (ADA) states, “Pregnant women can help ensure
their children get a good start on their oral health by focusing
on staying healthy, including a proper diet, because teeth begin
developing between the third and sixth month of pregnancy.” (15)
Breastmilk is the healthiest choice for a young child’s overall
development. It also has anti-cariogenic properties and is an
important factor in keeping teeth healthy. Breastmilk contains
bacteria fighting cells and enzymes, which may help destroy the
germs that cause tooth decay. (16) (17)
As children begin eating solid foods, continuing to provide a
well balanced diet, rich in fresh fruits and vegetables, is beneficial
to good dental health.
References:
(1) CBC News, December 1998,
http://cbc.ca/cgi-bin/templates/view.cgi?category=Sci-Tech&story=/news/1998/12/29/fluoride981229
(2)”Prevalence and trends in enamel fluorosis in the United States
from the 1930s to the 1980s.” by Beltran-Aguilar, et al, Journal
of the American Dental Association, February 2002
(3) “Recommendations for Using Fluoride to Prevent and Control
Dental Caries in the United States” August 27, 2001, CDC
http://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/rr5014a1.htm
(4)”Preventive dentistry: practitioners' recommendations for
low-risk patients compared with scientific evidence and practice
guidelines,” Am J Prev Med Feb 2000 , by Frame et al
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&
db=PubMed&list_uids=10698247&dopt=Abstract
(5) “The case for eliminating the use of the dietary fluoride
supplements for young children,” J Public Health Dentistry 1999
Fall by BA Burt
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&
db=PubMed&list_uids=10682335&dopt=Abstract
(6) Letter from New Jersey Representative Kelly to FDA
http://www.citizens.org/Food_water_safety/Fluoridation/Materials/
web_pages/letter%20_%20to_FDA.htm and confirmed by Crystal
Wyand, spokesperson, FDA's Center for Drug Evaluation and Research,
e-mail correspondence.
(7) “More Rigorous Studies Needed to Advance Emerging Dental
Caries Diagnostic and Management Strategies, Says NIH Consensus
Panel,” NIH News Release, March 28, 2001
http://consensus.nih.gov/news/releases/115_release.htm and
British Medical Journal (B.M.J.), October 7, 2000,McDonagh, et
al
(8) “Dentistry, Dental Practice and the Community,” by Burt and
Eklund.
(9) Journal of the California Dental Association, January 1997,
“The Fluoride Victory,” by Joanne Boyd
(10) "The Metabolism and Toxicity of Fluoride," by
Gary Whitford and
http://pmeiers.bei.t-online.de/burton.htm
(11) http://pmeiers.bei.t-online.de/kennerly.htm
(12) “Acute fluoride poisoning from a public water system,” New
England Journal of Medicine, Jan 1994, Gessner et al,
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd
=Retrieve&db=PubMed&list_uids=8259189&dopt=Abstract
and http://www.fluoridealert.org/leaks-spills.htm
(13) “Health Journal: As kids' cavities rise, some dentists advocate
using tooth sealants,”Wall Street Journal, Tara Parker-Pope, March
8, 2002
http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/news/archive/
2002/03/08/financial1058EST0079.DTL
(14) “Nutrition and physical Degeneration,” by Weston A. Price
D.D.S.
(15)
http://www.ada.org/public/media/newsrel/0202/nr-01.html
ADA News Releases
February 2002
Good Oral Health Begins in the Womb
(16) Loesche WJ, "Nutrition and dental decay in infants."
Am J Clin Nutr 41; 423-435, 1985
(17) Lucas, A, Cole T, "Is Breast Feeding a Likely Cause
of Dental Caries in young Children?" Journal of American
Dental Assoc., 1979; 98:21-23