Advanced Search
Dr Jay's FAQs
Pediatricks™
Nutrition
Attachment Parenting
Breastfeeding
Alternative Medicine
Link Library
Recommended Reading

Any and all advertisements you might see on this website are 100% uncompensated recommendations. I like Sinupret because it looks clean, is well-tested and I think it works. I recommend Erbaorganics because they're very clear about the percentage of organic ingredients in each of their products. At one time, I received some free samples from these two companies. I no longer do. If you buy my DVD, I think I get about fifty cents. Unless you choose to buy thousands and thousands of my books, I'll never see one penny in royalties. Jay
Vaccinations?  DVD


Visit www.erbaorganics.com

Visit www.bionoricausa.com

Visit the Natural Child Project Website


Vaccines—A Brief Newer Note, August 2004

By Dr. Jay Gordon


We give too many vaccines at once. Certainly there’s no proof that we are “overwhelming the immune system” as some say, but this is not the best way to vaccinate America’s or the world’s children.

Most experts agree that global vaccination policy has prevented and continues to prevent millions of cases of dangerous illnesses and even small changes in these protocols in developing nations could lead to recurrence of epidemics. This is not the topic that I address in my pediatric practice or in this article.

I care for one child at a time and when writing I am speaking of healthy children in healthy families with access to modern medical care. My opinion remains a minority point of view with the vest majority of experts and doctors supporting the current vaccination schedule.

I believe that certain vaccines are relevant to my pediatric patients’ lives and certain are not. During my office day, I discuss risks and benefits of all medical interventions. For instance, giving antibiotics to a child with an ear infection carries only a very small risk, but the benefits are even smaller. “Watchful waiting” is the best policy and is endorsed by pediatric associations in many countries. On the other hand, I child with pneumonia will get antibiotics in my office because the benefits outweigh the risks.

Vaccines can be similarly evaluated: If a family is planning two years in Haiti, Somalia or Nigeria working as missionaries to the sick and poor, the benefits of most vaccines far outweigh any risks. If a family’s travel includes flying to Hawaii, New York City or Paris, there is very little risk of coming into contact with the diseases against which we immunize.

The vaccine that has the best risk/benefit ratio is the DTaP. Diphtheria is virtually never found in America or other parts of the Western Hemisphere, tetanus is quite difficult to contract of your immune system is healthy, but whooping cough (pertussis) is always around and is a very nasty illness. I still think that this vaccine should be given later in the first year of life rather than at six weeks of age and that it should not be given with 3 or 4 other shots. I often include the HIB vaccine with the DTaP because I remember when that type of meningitis was still around in great quantity and, even now, rare cases are still reported. (Tetanus is reported 40-50 times each year in the USA and one case of diphtheria is reported every 12-24 months.)

Hepatitis B vaccination at birth has proved to be excellent national health care policy but I don’t think that the benefits outweigh the risk for a newborn. Hep B is a disease contracted through high-risk behavior. The disease is not one of childhood and the shot has harmed newborns. Polio vaccination is no longer needed in America according to many experts. Fewer than 1000 cases of polio have been reported each of the past few years and the publicity about hundreds of additional cases of polio in Nigeria has been met with renewed commitment to vaccinate in that and other African nations.

I think that the MMR vaccine needs quite a bit of study and am disgusted that official scientific bodies have ignored evidence linking this vaccine to problems and have stated that “no further studies need be done.” This scientifically unsound attitude serves no one.

The flu shot will have mercury as a preservative again this year. There will be more mercury than ever before. I do not recommend this vaccine except in very special cases. Healthy children and adults should not receive this shot. It is rarely “on target” in protecting against the specific strain of influenza each winter.

In summary: Talk to your doctor but please realize that all of us are barraged by advertising, free pens, free dinners and more. Vaccinations are the most difficult topic for some pediatricians. I do not want to get on television or write a book talking about “how terrible” vaccines are. This is far too broad a generalization and completely inaccurate. Polio vaccination and measles vaccination and rubella vaccination and more have saved many, many lives. I am very wiling to say that the way we vaccinate our infants now is not the best medical care for them.